| 2001 |  Grand Mountain Adventure: WonderlandsToppluva AB | 84.6% | 92% | 325 | 1 | $19.99 |
| 2002 |  Dungeon ScavengerVidama Software LLC | 83.9% | 95% | 104 | 0 | $7.99 |
| 2003 |  Fate/hollow ataraxia REMASTEREDTYPE-MOON | 90.2% | 96% | 983 | 24 | $29.99 |
| 2004 |  One Potion PleaseCoderGuy111 | 86.5% | 96% | 185 | 6 | $2.99 |
| 2005 |  Within the BackroomsShattered Display | 86.1% | 95% | 213 | 0 | −20%$7.99$6.39 |
| 2006 |  Papa's Mocharia DeluxeFlipline Studios | 89.2% | 95% | 887 | 84 | $5.99 |
| 2007 |  Vertigo RemasteredZach Tsiakalis-Brown | 87.2% | 92% | 1,338 | 0 | $19.99 |
| 2008 |  Air TwisterYS NET | 81.7% | 92% | 106 | 0 | $24.99 |
| 2009 |  The Happyhills Homicide 2: Out For BloodCopperbolt | 88.9% | 95% | 763 | 1 | $2.99 |
| 2010 |  Eternal AfternoonAlex Klexber | 87.9% | 95% | 459 | 1 | $8.99 |
| 2011 |  Attack on ToysN7T-GAMES | 87.9% | 93% | 1,177 | 14 | $6.99 |
| 2012 |  Dreamline 404Daydreamin Blu | 86.9% | 96% | 218 | 0 | Free |
| 2013 |  绮罗四时谭EveRecord | 88.7% | 96% | 459 | 0 | Free |
| 2014 |  Demons Never LieIndieBug | 85.2% | 92% | 429 | 0 | $3.99 |
| 2015 |  VOCÊ É UM DEFUNTO MECÂNICOVirgula Leal | 89.4% | 97% | 416 | 0 | Free |
| 2016 |  So to SpeakErik Andersen | 85.1% | 96% | 120 | 1 | $17.99 |
| 2017 |  Tree Simulator 2021Revmatek | 81.5% | 92% | 100 | 0 | $3.99 |
| 2018 |  Legend of GrimrockAlmost Human Games | 89.7% | 93% | 4,868 | 35 | $14.99 |
| 2019 |  Sakura Hime 3GirlGames | 88.2% | 95% | 535 | 0 | $3.99 |
| 2020 |  A YEAR OF SPRINGSnpckc | 91.9% | 98% | 938 | 0 | $4.99 |
| 2021 |  The Repairing MantisErupting Avocado | 84.7% | 95% | 133 | 0 | $5.99 |
| 2022 |  AlpacalypseGus McGuire | 82.8% | 92% | 155 | 0 | Free |
| 2023 |  The Lion's Song: Episode 1 - SilenceMi'pu'mi Games GmbH | 87.9% | 92% | 2,254 | 0 | Free |
| 2024 |  PEGArzola's | 84.1% | 92% | 252 | 0 | $0.99 |
| 2025 |  Hidden Cats in Jigsaw PuzzleNukearts Studio | 82.7% | 93% | 114 | 1 | Free |
| 2026 |  The End Is NighEdmund McMillen | 89.3% | 93% | 3,329 | 16 | $14.99 |
| 2027 |  Cozy Mergeat0m | 85.2% | 95% | 155 | 0 | $1.99 |
| 2028 |  My Furry Protogen 2 🐾Dirty Fox Games | 88.8% | 96% | 472 | 1 | $4.99 |
| 2029 |  BalanticaTeam Hanzan | 83.0% | 92% | 163 | 0 | Free |
| 2030 |  Stranger Maidens Please Protect Me!Volcanic Good Boy | 83.0% | 92% | 165 | 3 | $10.99 |
| 2031 |  SummonGoosix Games | 88.2% | 92% | 3,010 | 1 | −51%$0.99$0.49 |
| 2032 |  DEATH IN UNISONBlank Dream Studios | 89.5% | 96% | 674 | 4 | $8.99 |
| 2033 |  RogueEpyx, Inc. | 88.1% | 95% | 506 | 2 | $2.99 |
| 2034 |  Late BirdVladimir Slav | 83.5% | 94% | 114 | 0 | $0.99 |
| 2035 |  The HeartBeat猫柚工作室 | 86.3% | 98% | 108 | 0 | $0.99 |
| 2036 |  Mokoko X: The First DateNAISU | 81.7% | 92% | 104 | 0 | Free |
| 2037 |  Hell is Other DemonsCuddle Monster Games | 84.6% | 92% | 312 | 0 | $9.99 |
| 2038 |  Tournament ArkFaws | 83.1% | 93% | 132 | 1 | Free |
| 2039 |  Dinner with an OwlBoringSuburbanDad | 88.3% | 94% | 883 | 0 | Free |
| 2040 |  Freefall '95S-Bend Games | 87.0% | 99% | 105 | 0 | $11.99 |
| 2041 |  ShardpunkClockwork Pile | 86.3% | 92% | 746 | 4 | $13.99 |
| 2042 |  SimuLadronJokai Studio | 87.4% | 94% | 549 | 0 | $0.99 |
| 2043 |  Ethereal EnigmaPixelFade | 87.2% | 94% | 485 | 0 | — |
| 2044 |  Witching StoneAlexander Taylor | 83.0% | 92% | 165 | 0 | $13.99 |
| 2045 |  Squiggle FootballMax Barry | 83.4% | 93% | 144 | 0 | $16.99 |
| 2046 |  ShatterSidhe | 88.6% | 95% | 662 | 0 | $1.99 |
| 2047 |  IZGUB 2001Dbrhdk | 85.7% | 97% | 113 | 0 | $3.99 |
| 2048 |  Thief II: The Metal AgeLooking Glass Studios | 88.6% | 93% | 1,949 | 12 | $6.99 |
| 2049 |  FINAL FANTASY IIISquare Enix | 89.0% | 93% | 2,694 | 42 | $17.99 |
| 2050 |  Socrates Jones: Pro PhilosopherIntelligible Games | 87.9% | 96% | 326 | 0 | Free |
