| 1951 |  Death HowlThe Outer Zone | 87.2% | 92% | 1,365 | 73 | −40%$19.99$11.99 |
| 1952 |  Gravitational PhenomenonTeamey | 84.4% | 95% | 120 | 0 | Free |
| 1953 |  Kriegsfront Tactics - PrologueToge Productions | 86.5% | 93% | 536 | 1 | Free |
| 1954 |  Melty Blood Actress Again Current CodeFRENCH-BREAD | 89.4% | 93% | 3,849 | 9 | $24.99 |
| 1955 |  Shipwrecked 64Squeaks D'Corgeh | 90.7% | 95% | 2,456 | 11 | $7.99 |
| 1956 |  My Dictator Stalin Can't Be This Cute ?!uwucorp | 84.4% | 92% | 290 | 1 | $1.49 |
| 1957 |  Monster CollegeMonster Eye Games | 87.8% | 95% | 448 | 8 | $9.99 |
| 1958 |  Zefyr: A Thief's MelodyOneiric Worlds | 87.7% | 95% | 417 | 4 | $4.83 |
| 1959 |  Heretic: Shadow of the Serpent RidersRaven Software | 88.8% | 94% | 1,172 | 4 | — |
| 1960 |  HER TREES : THE PUZZLE HOUSEStone | 88.6% | 94% | 1,052 | 4 | $1.99 |
| 1961 |  Farlanders: PrologueAndrii Bychkovskyi | 85.2% | 93% | 290 | 0 | Free |
| 1962 |  The Scourge | Tai ƯơngRare Reversee | 87.9% | 93% | 1,226 | 3 | $19.99 |
| 1963 |  With Shining EyesLucas Fisher | 82.6% | 93% | 109 | 0 | Free |
| 1964 |  Farming Simulator 2011GIANTS Software | 86.5% | 92% | 847 | 9 | $7.99 |
| 1965 |  UCOPIAYunTYB | 86.2% | 97% | 131 | 0 | Free |
| 1966 |  Bat BoyX PLUS Co., Ltd. | 84.2% | 94% | 146 | 0 | $14.99 |
| 1967 |  Backwoods TownAndrii Prots | 84.2% | 93% | 196 | 1 | $8.99 |
| 1968 |  Eriksholm: The Stolen DreamRiver End Games | 89.8% | 94% | 2,537 | 35 | −40%$39.99$23.99 |
| 1969 |  Blippo+YACHT | 87.7% | 95% | 422 | 1 | $14.99 |
| 1970 |  SeclusaStudio Niente | 86.7% | 97% | 154 | 1 | $12.99 |
| 1971 |  Trap GenesisNo Strike | 87.2% | 95% | 338 | 0 | $9.99 |
| 1972 |  Halo 3 Mod Tools - MCC343 Industries | 83.4% | 93% | 146 | 8 | — |
| 1973 |  StrugglingChasing Rats Games | 85.9% | 93% | 398 | 0 | $14.99 |
| 1974 |  RubiniteCup Dog Games | 90.5% | 94% | 4,546 | 47 | $19.99 |
| 1975 |  SpiderHeckNeverjam | 89.5% | 93% | 3,971 | 100 | −60%$14.99$5.99 |
| 1976 |  Cats Love BoxesDevcats | 89.5% | 97% | 437 | 1 | $3.99 |
| 1977 |  狼と香辛料VR/Spice&WolfVRSpicyTails | 86.8% | 92% | 1,060 | 0 | $24.99 |
| 1978 |  SudocatsDevcats | 92.9% | 98% | 1,738 | 6 | $1.99 |
| 1979 |  Quake III Arenaid Software | 91.1% | 95% | 3,493 | 23 | $14.99 |
| 1980 |  A day in East EuropeBogdan Rosca | 84.8% | 94% | 177 | 0 | $0.99 |
| 1981 |  Space ExpeditionMobirate | 84.2% | 93% | 192 | 0 | Free |
| 1982 |  Fear the MoonJonny's Games | 84.0% | 94% | 134 | 0 | $6.99 |
| 1983 |  Peace, Death!AZAMATIKA | 88.8% | 93% | 2,311 | 7 | $4.99 |
| 1984 |  Tanks: The CrusadesAehmttw (Matei Budiu) | 88.0% | 94% | 734 | 1 | Free |
| 1985 |  Please Knock on My DoorLevall Games AB | 84.7% | 93% | 239 | 0 | $12.99 |
| 1986 |  Plushie from the Skyfishwind | 88.2% | 96% | 367 | 0 | $11.99 |
| 1987 |  Pivot XLAdamvision Studios | 84.1% | 93% | 184 | 0 | $0.99 |
| 1988 |  Kyle is Famous: Complete EditionJohn Szymanski | 85.9% | 95% | 199 | 0 | $9.99 |
| 1989 |  We Escaped a Twisted GameDeluded Games | 88.2% | 94% | 828 | 9 | $4.99 |
| 1990 |  Kakenuke★Forward to Our Sparking Youth!SAGA PLANETS | 84.2% | 93% | 192 | 1 | $29.99 |
| 1991 |  WhiteClothesMokomuGame | 84.1% | 93% | 187 | 31 | Free |
| 1992 |  Jet LancerCode Wakers | 87.0% | 92% | 1,170 | 0 | $14.99 |
| 1993 |  Mosaique Neko Waifus 4Lil Hentai Games | 90.4% | 94% | 4,253 | 0 | $4.99 |
| 1994 |  DMT: Dynamic Music TesseractDMT | 83.5% | 92% | 200 | 0 | $4.99 |
| 1995 |  Love Sucks: Night OneArt Witch Studios | 88.7% | 94% | 1,114 | 2 | Free |
| 1996 |  Mega Mall StoryKairosoft Co.,Ltd | 86.2% | 94% | 309 | 0 | $8.99 |
| 1997 |  DownfallHarvester Games | 89.1% | 94% | 1,476 | 3 | $8.99 |
| 1998 |  Air TwisterYS NET | 81.7% | 92% | 106 | 0 | $24.99 |
| 1999 |  House of 1000 Doors: Family SecretsFive BN | 86.7% | 97% | 152 | 4 | $6.99 |
| 2000 |  Zniw AdventureAzure Mountain | 90.0% | 99% | 274 | 0 | $8.99 |
